Showing posts with label Calvert Formation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Calvert Formation. Show all posts

Friday, March 29, 2024

Confounded Dolphin Teeth: More From the Chronicles of the Demise of My Fossil Collection

Many of the fossils I painstakingly collected over the years have entered into a curious limbo, resting now in gallon-sized plastic baggies that are distinguished only by general category of fossil (teeth, shells, etc.) and where found.  These fossils await a final disposition though I do know they won’t be kept.  (My previous post described what a poor job I did of curating the bulk of the collection.)  So far, a few fossils have resisted the deconstruction process as I’ve filled these large bags.  The pufferfish fossils highlighted in the previous post are one example.  A second group of fossils has managed to distract me and avoid the fate of those fossils in the big baggies.  This is a small clutch of tiny dolphin teeth collected along the shoreline of the Calvert Cliffs where the Calvert Formation is exposed (the portion of that formation yielding these teeth dates from possibly a bit less than 17 to about 14 million years ago).  I initially set them aside for two reasons:  I find them beautiful in their simplicity and, until now, I had never attempted to try and assign them to Miocene dolphin genus and species.  (Clearly, decommissioning my fossil collection will take forever if this is going to be my usual pattern of behavior.)


[Later edit:  Is it possible there are bony fish teeth mixed in with these?  I don't think so, but that would definitely confound this exercise even more.]

This post is focused on this effort in taxonomy and (to end any suspense) why it was a failure, despite the apparent diversity in teeth shown above.  I will acknowledge at the outset that much of that "diversity" is likely due to how worn these teeth are.  Nevertheless, there's a bit of a story about dolphin teeth to be told.

Some initial groundwork with terminology and relationships is necessary.  The cetaceans (commonly slapped with the general label whales) are divided into two main groups.  The odontocetes or toothed whales are a taxon which also includes dolphins and porpoises.  The other large category of cetaceans are the mysticetes or baleen whales.  Another point of clarification.  The small cetacean teeth I collected from the Calvert Cliffs shoreline are most likely from dolphins and should not be ascribed to porpoises:  the latter, extant from perhaps the mid Miocene onward, were denizens of the Pacific, and, reportedly, their fossils are particularly scarce prior to the Pleistocene.  (For more on this issue concerning porpoises, see text by Joy Pierce Herrington, in Fossil Marine Mammals (Digital Version), Volume IV of IV - Part 2, North Carolina Fossil Club, edited by Richard Chandler, 2017, pages 6, 118.)

Early on in this taxonomic endeavor, I was encouraged by learning of the recent publication of a superb description of the various toothed whales of the Calvert Cliffs written by paleontologists Stephen J. Godfrey and Olivier Lambert.  (Miocene Toothed Whales (Odontoceti) from Calvert Cliffs, Atlantic Coastal Plain, USA, Chapter 2 in The Geology and Vertebrate Paleontology of Calvert Cliffs, Maryland, USA, Volume 2, Turtles and Toothed Whales, edited by Stephen J. Godfrey, Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology, Number 107, 2023.)  It is an expansive treatise on these odontocetes, including discussions and descriptions of 16 dolphin species whose fossils have been found in material shed from the portion of the Calvert Formation along which I collected my dolphin teeth.  (This count is based on Figure 2.73 which lists the named odontocetes by stratigraphy.  I have assumed, possibly in error, that Shattuck-Zones 8 to 13 are responsible for my teeth.)

Yet, this volume, for all of its many merits, turns out to be a thin reed (at least for me) upon which to attempt any extensive taxonomic attribution of the dolphin teeth I have on hand.  I went so far as to create a spreadsheet listing each of the dolphin species described by Godfrey and Lambert, excerpting any text about, or pictures featuring, teeth.  A few of the authors’ descriptions and images prompted one or two rash and wild guesses as to identity, but I ultimately concluded not to suggest any.  Discretion is by far the better part of valor in this instance.  Beyond the Godfrey and Lambert volume, I searched extensively elsewhere for some sort of single guide to fossil dolphin teeth, something similar to the many volumes devoted to fossil shark teeth, and came up empty.  Clearly, I hoped someone had done the heavy lifting in creating such a guide.

There are several key reasons why my taxonomic exercise failed.  I have already mentioned the evident wear and tear on my specimens.  But, in reality, at the heart of my difficulties is the profound impact of evolution on the earliest harbingers of the cetacea that made their way from the land back to the water.  Dolphins, like all of the other toothed whales, evolved from mammals that had typically mammalian teeth with highly varied morphology.  Consider the differences among the teeth in your own mouth.  Over time, as the stem odontocetes evolved to become fully aquatic, their teeth changed markedly.  I was quite taken by a paragraph on these evolutionary changes to their teeth written by paleontologist Steve Brusatte in his terrific book The Rise and Reign of the Mammals:  A New History From the Shadow of the Dinosaurs to Us (2022).

Gone are all the complex cusps and ridges; gone is the lineup of incisors, canines, premolars, and molars; gone is the replacement of baby teeth with adult teeth; gone is the ability to chew.  Instead, all the teeth are conical pegs, which simply cut meat off fish or other whales, which the odontocete then swallows.  Some odontocetes barely use their teeth in feeding and lazily swallow their prey whole.  (p. 280)

I drew three key conclusions from Brusatte’s overview of the changes that occurred.

First, the end result of the process is, in his words, “conical pegs.”  Yes, the conical or peg-like aspect to all of these teeth renders them relatively indistinguishable without close study.  This is unlike fossil shark teeth which come in a plethora of different shapes and sizes which are key to sorting them by genus and species, a task relatively easy for some of them.  (By the way, the teeth of porpoises are not conical but, rather, spatulate or cupped at their end.)

That said, there is in fact some diversity in the dolphin teeth that could be found along the Calvert Cliffs.  At the most extreme, there are the teeth from the three species of the Squalodontidae family that are present here.  The squalodons or, as they are sometimes called, “shark toothed dolphins,” have very distinctive teeth.    Consider those depicted below which appeared in the Godfrey and Lambert volume (figure 2.2, scale bar is 10mm).

Certainly, a couple of these are nothing like the Calvert Formation dolphin teeth in my collection.

Godfrey and Lambert do identify a few potentially distinguishing features of the teeth of several other dolphin species, ranging from tiny cusplets to keels running down the teeth.  Nevertheless, given the state of my dolphin teeth and the inherent "sameness" of nearly all such teeth, I don’t feel I have the necessary guidance I need to go further.  Frankly, it's true that, by and large, Miocene odontocete teeth (other than those from squalodons) are reasonably and justifiably covered by Brusatte’s descriptive phrase “conical pegs.”  Further, isolated odontocete teeth (excepting those of squalodons) are seldom appropriately diagnostic as to genus or species.  This specific point is made quite convincingly by a paleontologist on the discussion site The Fossil Forum in an exchange of messages regarding a search for ID guides to odontocete teeth.  He posted on June 11, 2013:  "I have one piece of advice for you:  Prepare for failure and disappointment.  The general attitude amongst marine mammal researchers is that, with the exception of really distinctive species, isolated odontocete teeth are generally not identifiable even to the genus level, and often not even to the family level. . . .  Odontocete teeth do not preserve the same breadth of diagnostic information that shark teeth have."

A second point to be made from Brusatte’s description is that it suggests that teeth in the jaws of odontocetes are homodont, that is, they do not really vary in morphology by location on the maxilla or mandible – top, bottom, front, or back of the jaws, the teeth are all similar, which they generally are.  Godfrey and Lambert label the teeth of odontocetes (other than squalodons) as “roughly homodont.”  This works to reinforce the sameness of the fossil dolphin teeth we might find along the shoreline.

(As an aside, at this point it strikes me that, were dolphins cartilaginous like sharks, that is, not having a bony skeleton, the work of paleontologists like Godfrey and Lambert would be incredibly more difficult.  Having the remains of bony skeletons to aid in determining genus and species makes a critical difference.)

Finally, Brusatte noted that, in the course of their lives, odontocetes have a single set of teeth.  The impact of this on the relative abundance of odontocete teeth fossils is significant.  I’ll acknowledge that some Miocene dolphins and extant dolphins are very much polydonts, that is, they have many teeth, some species a couple of hundred or more.  Nevertheless, when one considers that an individual shark might in its life span shed tens of thousands of teeth, it’s no wonder shark teeth litter the shoreline along the Calvert Cliffs, while dolphin teeth don’t.

All of this adds up to what I found to be insurmountable hurdles for assigning the teeth I have to genus, much less species, and helps explain the "missing" guide to fossil odontocete teeth.

In conclusion, although I won't be assigning my dolphin teeth to genus and species and, as a result, they will remain unknown, I will assign them to the “keep” category.  Beauty, simplicity, and relative scarcity win out.  So, a bunch of teeth that I can only assign to a collecting location and the broad category of “dolphin teeth,” nevertheless avoids the bardo to which I’ve condemned many fossils from my collection, some of which could be identified.  Quite ironic!

Saturday, January 12, 2013

Strange Small Eruptions


  
Horatio         In what particular thought to work I know not;
     But in the gross and scope of my opinion,
     This bodes some strange eruption to our state.
~ Hamlet, Act I, Scene I

I haven’t thought through the precise implications of my fascination with the world of microfossils, but in general I sense that it “bodes some strange eruption to our state.”  Perhaps not tragedy, but certainly change in behavior. 

Case in point, the fossil shell pictured below.  It prompted new behavior and led to some small eruptions (though nothing really earthshaking).


In a recent post, I initially identified this shell as coming from an Ecphora tricostata.  I have reason to think something’s rotten in my analysis, given the location where it was found (Scientists’ Cliffs), the formation I think it came from (Calvert), and the likely age of the material (Middle Miocene – some 16 to 12 million years old).  The definitive study of the stratigraphy of this area posits that E. meganae, not E. tricostata, is found in these portions of the Calvert Formation, but my fossil favors the latter more than the former.  (Lauck W. Ward and George W. Andrews, Stratigraphy of the Calvert, Choptank, and St. Marys Formations (Miocene) in The Chesapeake Bay Area, Maryland and Virginia, Virginia Museum of Natural History, 2008.)

It’s symptomatic of my current obsession with the micro that, rather than continue to puzzle over the identification of this Ecphora, I am now consumed by the gray clay matrix that surrounded and filled the shell.  Some three months ago, when I prepared the fossil, I ignored some expert advice and removed the matrix from what, unfortunately, turned out to be a rather fragile shell.  In the process, the internal, central pillar (columella) broke free.  A shame.

But, in a move that I recognized at the time as somewhat quixotic and strange, I bagged the matrix I removed from the shell, slapped a label on the bag, and set it aside.

A couple of weeks ago, I came across the bag and thought, “What the hell, let’s see what’s in here.”

I wont go through the tedious details of my amateurish handling of these few grams of Miocene material, except to say that it involved one percent solutions of Calgon (in water), lots of soaking, lots of sieving, but no baking.  And still it’s plagued with lumps.  (The comedy of errors that is my preparation of material for microfossil searching is described in painful detail in a previous post.  I’ve added some scientific sieves to my equipment, providing a patina of the professional to my inherently sophomoric efforts.)

There was something of the miraculous when, under the microscope, from the gray miasma of this matrix, intricate microfossils made their first appearance, ghosts of minute Miocene fauna.  Amazing what now gets my heart racing.

From within that fractured Ecphora came a flood of foraminifera shells, accompanied by a much  sparser scattering of ostracode shells.  Remarkably, despite several hours of picking, I haven’t exhausted this sample yet.  At this juncture, the critical limit to my time before the microscope is what my hunched over shoulders can bear.

Though I am retrieving foraminifera shells in many different and complex shapes, it’s a couple of shells from the ostracodes, those miniscule crustaceans, that have captured my imagination for the moment.  These two fossils are ornate, exploding with blunt and pointed spines.  Among the many spines are some that, upon closer examination, form three curved rows marking portions of the length of each shell.


These two specimens are both about 0.8 mm long.  Ostracodes have right and left valves hinged at the dorsal edge (top edge of each specimen in the photograph).  The top specimen shown is a right valve, the bottom one is a left valve (the valves are certainly from two individuals).

I’ve identified this Miocene ostracode as Actinocythereis exanthemata (Ulrich and Bassler, 1904).  My primary source for this identification is Richard M. Forester’s paper titled A Systematic Revision of the Ostracode Species Described by Ulrich and Bassler and by Malkin from the Chesapeake Group in Maryland and Virginia (U.S. Geological Survey, Geological Survey Professional Paper 1128, 1980, p. 11 and plate 3, figures 7 and 8).

In 1904, E.O. Ulrich and R.S. Bassler, wrote the initial description of this species for the Maryland Geological Survey’s Miocene: Text (Volume I, 1904, p. 117-118).  They contributed the Ostracoda discussion to the Systematic Paleontology portion of the book.  Amid their lengthy characterization of this fossil, which they named Cythere exanthemata, is a pithy phrase that nicely captures the essence of their description – this ostracode shell has an “extremely nodose and spiny carapace.”  (p. 117)

Nodose challenged my vocabulary, but it’s a great word.  According to the New Oxford American Dictionary, it's an adjective meaning “having or characterized by hard or tight lumps; knotty.”  The neat noun form is nodosity.  Savor that word.  Makes sense that nodule has the same Latin root.

Here are the drawings of C. exanthemata that Ulrich and Bassler included among the plates in the second volume of the work on the Maryland Miocene.


 They acknowledged some concern about precisely where C. exanthemata should come to rest taxonomically, but noted they were at work on a monograph which, “it is hoped, may result in a more natural and serviceable classification of the fossil species than the one now in use.”  I don’t think they ever followed through on this.  The taxonomic history of A. exanthemata prepared by Forester in 1980 includes no subsequent publication of theirs.

Now, of the 1904 duo who tackled the Maryland Miocene ostracodes, Ulrich had the reputation of being a splitter – seeing different species where others didn’t.  I’m not certain about Bassler in this regard.  (The career paths of the two men intrigue me and will be the subject of a future post.)

As a post-doctoral fellow at the U.S. Geological Survey, Forester reanalyzed the taxonomic decisions regarding these ostracodes made by Ulrich and Bassler in 1904 and several D.S. Malkin had made in a 1953 article (Biostratigraphic Study of Miocene Ostracoda of New Jersey, Maryland, and Virginia, Journal of Paleontology).  Forester concluded that Ulrich and Bassler were guilty of both splitting and lumping.  In some instances, they identified males, females, and juveniles of the same species as distinct species.  In others, the array of specimens they offered as examples of a single species should have been considered different species under current practice.  So, he redid the species.

Unfortunately, even after Forester’s work, the identification of A. exanthemata is, in my eyes, still rather obscure.  In his treatment of A. exanthemata, Forester drew a fine distinction among specimens that previous researchers had considered of the same species.  He concluded that figure 4 in the Ulrich and Bassler’s drawings of C. exanthemata (see above) was actually A. marylandica.  (Ulrich and Bassler noted that figure 4 was a drawing of the largest specimen of the purported species that they'd found.)  Forester acknowledged that “Actinocythereis exanthemata is most frequently confused with the lower Miocene to Holocene species A. marylandica (Howe and Hough, 1935),” and identified similar instances of this confusion by other researchers in the decades since 1904.  But, he asserted, A. marylandica is “larger and more robust” and has a “slightly different” spine arrangement.

That’s not much help for me, actually.  The size distinction isn’t useful without more specimens to work with and, it’s not really certain that any differences in the configuration of the spines are evidence of much.  In a later study of South Carolina ostracodes, Thomas M. Cronin commented that “[t]he degree of variability in the spines precludes separation [of these two species] on the basis of this characteristic.”  (Evolution of Neogene and Quaternary marine Ostracode, United States Atlantic Coastal Plain:  Evolution and speciation in Ostracoda, IV, appearing in Studies Related to the Charleston, South Carolina Earthquake of 1886 – Neogene and Quaternary Lithostratigraphy and Biostratigraphy, U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1367, 1990, p. c-35.)

[Later edit:  I dropped a paragraph from the original post which suggested that the two species may actually be males and females of the same species.  I believe I misread a study by Frederick M. Swain (Some Upper Miocene and Pliocene(?) Ostracoda of Atlantic Coaster Region for Use in Hydrogeologic Studies, U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 821, 1974, p. 30.).]

Nevertheless, as far as I can unpack Forester’s description of A. exanthemata, I think my two specimens fit.  And, in this instance, I’m going to follow the National Football League approach (instant replay overrides the ruling on the field only in the face of indisputable evidence) and stay with A. exanthemata.

Of course, I also have a nonscientific motivation, I love that species name – exanthemata.  Its Greek root, exanthema, means “an eruption.”



[Much later and decidedly sheepish edit:  I'm really beginning to think that these two ostracode specimens may be from Henryhowella evax, not Actinocythereis at all.  H. evax is apparently more ovate than A. exanthemata.  Further, the spines on A. exanthemata appear more pronounced than those on the specimens above.  If this rethinking of mine is correct, it leaves me looking more than a bit foolish for having rambled on at length in this post about a couple of misidentified fossil ostracode shells.  My apologies.]

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Communities of Interest


Last week I was invited to collect fossils for the first time along Scientists’ Cliffs on the western shore of the Chesapeake Bay.  This is a rare treat for fossil hunters who don’t own property here (and don’t kayak) because the only access to the beach from the land side is across private property.


At these cliffs, part of the Calvert Cliffs, the dominant formations are middle Miocene (roughly 16 to 12 million years old).  The fossil material found here is likely to be a bit younger than what I find about 10 miles to the north (a couple of miles below Chesapeake Beach, Maryland) where I usually hunt.  In general, as one moves south down the Bay, the older (lower) formations sink beneath the beach and the younger (upper) formations make up more of the exposed cliffsides.

If I’d done my homework I would have expected to find some fossils here different from my usual suspects.  But, to be honest, I only anticipated a greater abundance of the same, assuming these beaches were not as scoured by collectors as those further north.  (I was wrong about that.)  The beach itself really doesn’t appear dramatically different at first glance, slumping cliffside here seems like slumping cliffside to the north.


But there are some telltale signs that things are actually very different.  For one, the cliffsides here don’t generally reach the heights they do to the north.  Certain familiar layers in the cliffs are dramatically thinner here or no longer even visible.  Yes, indeed, age and distance make a difference.  To the north, many of fossils are eroding out of the older Calvert Formation, while here the younger Choptank Formation plays a much stronger role in creating the community of fossils protruding from fallen blocks of clay and the gray sand on the beach, or swirling in the wash.  In both locations, Calvert and Choptank layers are exposed, so, neither contributes exclusively at one place or the other, but a much greater proportion of the northern cliffs are Calvert, while 10 miles south, the Choptank predominates.  Indeed, most of the Calvert has disappeared.  (Detailed information on the exposure of these formations along the Calvert Cliffs can be found in Stratigraphy of the Calvert, Choptank, and St. Marys Formations (Miocene) in the Chesapeake Bay Area, Maryland and Virginia, by Lauck W. Ward and George W. Andrews, Virginia Museum of Natural History, Memoir Number 9, 2008.)

The picture below captures a small segment of the fossil invertebrate faunal community I found along the Scientists’ Cliffs shore.


The centerpiece of this picture is the mollusk Chesapecten nefrens Ward and Blackwelder.  Though penetrated in places (by predators?  by being battered in the waves?) and marked by barnacles, this is a wonderful specimen because, despite its travails, its perimeter is complete.  To give a frame of reference for the sizes of this and the other fossils in the picture, the C. nefrens measures slightly more than 4.5 inches from top to bottom.  Though C. nefrens is common along the shores of the Calvert Cliffs, this specimen is much larger than any I’ve collected further north.  Harold E. Vokes et al., in Miocene Fossils of Maryland (2nd edition, Maryland Geological Survey, 1999), confirm this size difference between specimens from the Choptank Formation and those from the Calvert.  Further, they observe that Choptank specimens frequently appear with many large barnacles attached to them.  (Though I was guided by Vokes et al., any errors in the identification of this shell and the other specimens in this post are mine alone.  Corrections appreciated.)

At the bottom left in the picture is a small segment of an echinoderm (in this case a “sand dollar”) named Abertella aberti (Conrad).  Vokes et al. describe this animal as common in the Choptank, but typically found broken.  Like a pottery shard, this piece of sand dollar only hints at the grace and complexity of the patterns that adorn the entire surface of the A. aberti.  Below is a close-up of the A. aberti fragment and the drawing of the entire echinoderm that appears in Miocene Fossils of Maryland.



Continuing clockwise are two examples of the mollusk Anadara staminea (Say), not one I’d found in the north, and probably with good reason.  According to Vokes et al., A. staminea is “known only from the Choptank.”

At the upper left is a single example of what I believe is a Balanus concavus Bronn, one of the large barnacles (though this one isn’t particularly impressive) often adorning the shells of C. nefrens.  Barnacles hold a certain fascination for me because, most surprisingly, the animals creating these shells are crustaceans.

Finally, at the lower right corner of the picture, is a damaged example of the gastropod Ecphora tricostata Martin.  I have found these at times up north and so it makes sense that Vokes et al. write that this species is commonly found in the Calvert Formation.  They do note that is rarely discovered in the lower Choptank, so, perhaps the small block of clay in which this specimen was encased came from the Calvert layer still exposed here at Scientists’ Cliffs.

The beach offered me a distinctive community of invertebrates.  There is another distinctive community here.  Well, actually, up above me on the wooded, rolling land that stretches back from the cliff edge.  In the mid 1930s, G. Flippo Gravatt and his wife Annie Gravatt, both scientists with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, purchased 238 acres of land here.  They were on a mission to create “a colony for scientists and professional people of kindred spirit.”  (Shawn White, Scientists’ Cliffs:  An Abbreviated History, April 15, 2009.)  The site held myriad charms for the Gravatts, among them the fossils eroding from the cliffs.  But perhaps more attractive to Flippo Gravatt were the chestnut trees.  He had worked on the pathologies attacking the American chestnut tree and was one of the first scientists to breed these trees.  He “picked the land partly because it boasted a few surviving chestnut trees, and he built his own cabin there from chestnut logs.”  (American Chestnut:  The Life, Death, and Rebirth of a Perfect Tree, by Susan Freinkel, 2007, p. 148.)

In the autumn of 1935, the Gravatts and some colleagues dedicated the site, deciding to name it Scientists’ Cliffs, though that wasn’t the only name attached to it.  According to the history of the colony, Annie Gravatt anointed it “Flippo’s Folly.”  Several cabins were soon built, available initially for rent during the summer.  A more permanent colony emerged quickly with purchases of plots and the cabins.

From the outset it was intended to be a very select community.  Under the constitution and bylaws of the Scientists’ Cliffs Association, incorporated in 1937, only scientists could be members.  According to Susan Freinkel, that meant folks with PhDs.  “Later this was broadened to include all college graduates and then extended to those who had achieved recognized status in their profession without college degrees.”  (Scientists’ Cliffs:  An Abbreviated History.)

Management of the community evolved over time as an increasing number of people came to live here year round and infrastructure and other needs multiplied.  A Community Administrator is now responsible for addressing the quotidian needs of residents.  But the twice annual meetings of the Association, at which issues are discussed and decided, continue, thus ensuring the persistent of “[e]ssentially the atmosphere of a New England town meeting.”  (Scientist’s Cliffs:  An Abbreviated History.)

And then there’s the physical layout of the community, a wonderful mixture of cabins and houses nestled among the trees along winding roads.  Nature still predominates.  Curiously, though, I thought of St. Mary Mead, the home of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple.  No, Scientists' Cliffs is not an idyllic English village in appearance, but I had the same sense of this community as I do when contemplating the map of St. Mary Mead that appears in the Miss Marple mysteries - at its best, it offers a kind of sanctuary.  I suspect, as well, that, regardless of where in the English countryside Christie intended the community of St. Mary Mead to be located (about which there is some debate), fossils would be there, too.

Saturday, March 13, 2010

A Scientific Patina to an Unscientific Endeavor

I hunt for fossils along the western shoreline of the Chesapeake Bay, with the Calvert Cliffs towering over me as I walk the narrow beaches at their base.



So, I was pretty eager to read a recent article in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology by Christy C. Visaggi and Stephen J. Godfrey (marine biologist and paleontologist, respectively) in which they presented a quantitative analysis of the distribution of Miocene fossil shark teeth by genus and species along the Calvert Cliffs. [Variation in Composition and Abundance of Miocene Shark Teeth From Calvert Cliffs, Maryland, Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, January 2010]

To be honest, after reading it, my excitement was generated less by the interesting results of their study, and more by a key aspect of the methodology they used for sampling teeth from the cliffs. That provided me with one of those moments when my avocational interest in fossils might actually intersect with scientific analysis, and when I have a chance to make a fool of myself.

Let me set the scene. The Calvert Cliffs, stretching for more than 30 miles down the coast, are composed of sediments deposited periodically during a period of roughly 10 million years, from about 18 million years ago to about 8 mya during the Miocene Epoch. Erosion from the cliffs exposes a multitude of marine fossils. Some of these fossils are found in situ in the cliff face (digging is illegal in the cliffs on public land and legal on private land only with permission), but most are caught in the waves and then captured by collectors as “float” along the shore. The fossils from the Calvert Cliffs reflect the breathtakingly rich marine fauna that characterized this arm of the Atlantic Ocean that, during the Miocene (and earlier), ebbed and flowed here in the so-called Salisbury Embayment.

Three different formations make up the cliffs – the Calvert Formation deposited during the Early and Middle Miocene, the Choptank Formation deposited during the Middle Miocene, and the St. Mary’s Formation deposited in the Late Miocene. Significantly, these formations are tilted, sinking at the rate of about 11 ft/mile as one moves from north to south. As a result, the earliest (oldest) formation, the Calvert, is exposed only at the northern end of the western shoreline because it drops out of sight (and out of the reach of the forces of erosion) as one treks south along the cliffs, until only the St. Mary’s Formation is exposed at the southern end of the cliffs. For reasons that will be clear, my collecting is focused on the northern end, that is, on fossils eroding out of the Calvert Formation. The pictures above are of the Calvert Formation, though it is still beyond me to identify the specific layers shown.

Scientists Clench Their Teeth


Visaggi and Godfrey examined teeth secured in two independent ways – 1,866 teeth currently residing in museum collections gathered originally in situ from the various layers of the cliffs by collectors (presumably, professional scientists and others), and 24,409 teeth gathered along the shore as float material.

It’s this latter source of teeth where the story gets particularly interesting for me. These teeth were collected by Calvert Cliffs residents, volunteers with the Calvert Marine Museum (Solomons, Maryland), and members of the CMM fossil club, and were originally donated to the CMM’s Discovery Room where children search through sand to discover fossil shark teeth. During a three-year period, 40 donations with good provenance data were diverted to the analysis of shark teeth distribution along the cliffs.

The authors divided the aggregate float sample of over 24,000 teeth into ten unequal groups based on where along the cliff shoreline they were collected. For example, the group from the beach at the northernmost end was designated CC10 and contained 1,716 teeth, while the southernmost group was CC1 with 614 teeth. Each one of the ten groups was analyzed separately, as was the total float sample.

Each of these sources of teeth – the in situ collection and the float collection – comes with decided biases. Among the various biases discussed by the authors were these two:

Payoff bias
– Collectors of float material have a natural tendency to head north to hunt for teeth because that’s where, by reputation, the payoff is the biggest. In their analysis, the authors emphasized the proportional distribution of teeth for different sections of the cliffs in an effort to mitigate against that potential bias. They suggested that this fossil wealth in the north reflected a deep, open marine paleoenvironment highly supportive of sharks that prevailed when the Calvert Formation was being laid down.

Size and Prize bias – Most collectors are likely to be biased against small teeth through a lack of interest in them or an inability to spot them. Teeth that are large, rare, or unusual are likely to be the focus of collectors’ energy. Interestingly, the authors conclude these sought-after teeth were likely to be overrepresented among the in situ teeth (adding these to a museum’s collection would be a priority), but underrepresented among the float teeth (the typical collector of these teeth would keep the best finds). The authors suggested that for the large, rare, or unusual teeth, the actual proportional representation would fall between those of the in situ and the float samples.

Scientific Guise

I appreciate the cleverness in amassing over 24,000 teeth from donations to the museum to create an impressive sample of teeth from the cliffs. Despite the clear biases and limitations of relying on float material, the sheer number of teeth suggests some confidence in what can be gleaned from this sample. Still, there might some interesting idiosyncrasies of float collectors that influence what is gathered.

[Later edit: I dropped a paragraph in which I speculated about other biases of float collectors and the number of individuals who might have been involved. It was misdirected because I failed to realize that 40 donations might have involved lots of people contributing to each donation, not a maximum of 40 contributing the whole sample (which raised the question of just a few collectors influencing the whole).]

So, what’s a rank amateur to do? Explore the idiosyncrasies, of course. I decided to devote my next trip to the Calvert Cliffs to answering this question:

How does the distribution of genus and species among the teeth I might collect on a single day compare to the distribution of the float sample reported by Visaggi and Godfrey?


A foolish venture, I recognize. One that was patently unscientific – a single sample taken by one collector on one day for, it turned out, three and a half hours (my back could only take so much stooping and bending on the beach) certainly doesn’t carry any weight. Any divergence from the paper’s results could be easily explained away. But, my motives were pure, I think, and it gave the trip some structure and I could delude myself that it added a very thin scientific patina to the effort. Plus, it was a damned sight more fun than going back through the teeth I had already collected from the Calvert Formation to see what their distribution looked like.

Let’s start with a few of my credentials to engage in this folly. I am a collector of float material and I reflect the payoff bias in spades since my collecting from the Calvert Cliffs is concentrated in an area at the northern end where the float samples CC10 (1,716 teeth) and, possibly, CC9 (7,523 teeth) came from.

It’s interesting to consider the possible influence of the size and prize bias on my collecting this day. I clearly have this bias – it’s hard not to. But, since I wasn’t donating my finds, it wouldn’t matter for the results. I wouldn’t be skimming off the “good stuff.” As for the tiny stuff, I decided to gather up every tooth that I spotted, regardless of size. This resolution presumably didn’t reflect one held by the collectors of the float material in the Visaggi and Godfrey study. Also, to be honest, I couldn’t follow through on this for the entire three and a half hours I was collecting. For roughly the last hour, I just couldn’t bear to stoop for yet another speck washing up around my boots.

What the Scientists Found

First, I think it’s appropriate to review the general results that Visaggi and Godfrey present in their paper because they are broadly relevant to my little exercise.

1) Overall, along the Calvert Cliffs, teeth come predominantly from gray or requiem sharks (Carcharhinus spp.), sand tiger sharks (Carcharias spp.), tiger sharks (Galeocerdo spp.), snaggletooth sharks (Hemipristis serra), and mako sharks (Isurus spp.). (“spp.” is the plural abbreviation for species – in other words, there are multiple species within the specific genus.)

2) The vast majority, about 90%, of all teeth, in situ or float, are found in the generally northern end of this expanse of shoreline, the section associated with the Calvert Formation.

3) The further south one goes, the relative distribution of teeth from these five genera of sharks changes – grays and sand tigers diminish in their representation among the teeth being found, while teeth from snaggletooth sharks and makos increase proportionately.

Relevant Study Samples Meet Mine

More relevant than their overall findings for my project were the results from the float samples Visaggi and Godfrey analyzed that came from the stretch of beach where I collect. This is principally the sample they identified as CC10, though it’s unclear precisely where the boundary between CC9 and CC10 falls. I suspect my wanderings took me from CC10 across that boundary, hence I not only compared my sample to the CC10 results, but also to a second aggregate sample I created from data in the article for CC9 added to that for CC10.

My sample consisted of the 157 teeth I collected on one cold, windy day in March, from about 2 hours before low tide to about 1 ½ hours after. Lots of wave action, and steady erosion from the cliffs. Little feeling in my fingers. Altogether, a typical winter day at the bay.

Results

The table and graphic below present the relative distribution among the genera accounting for the largest proportion of teeth found. Any genus accounting for at least 1% of the total of any specific sample – mine, CC10, or CC9+10 – is included. These eight genera include the five listed above and the following: cow sharks (Notorynchus primigenius), lemon sharks (Negaprion eurybathrodon), and hammerhead sharks (Sphyrna laevissima). These eight account for between 87% (my teeth) and 92% (CC10) of the teeth in these samples.



































































Genus/SpeciesMy TeethCC10 TeethCC9+10 Teeth




Notorynchus primigenius0%4.6%1.2%
Carcharias spp.7.6%10.1%8.8%
Isurus spp.3.2%4.5%2.5%
Hemipristis serra7.0%8.0%9.4%
Carcharhinus spp.45.2%56.9%50.7%
Galeocerdo spp.17.2%7.0%17.6%
Negaprion eurybathrodon3.8%0.1%0.1%
Sphyrna laevissima2.6%0.6%0.9%





Some nice examples of teeth in these predominant categories are shown below. This first one contains some teeth from grays.


This next picture shows some tiger shark teeth. These are all from the contortus species. (In this little exercise, I’ve followed Visaggi and Godfrey in grouping these specific teeth under the Galeocerdo genus.)


A few sand tiger shark teeth.


Finally, a trio of snaggletooth teeth, all three of these are uppers and would be pointing down in the shark’s mouth – two have serious root damage and the third is quite pretty.


Discussion

So, what was learned? Well, though I doubt this will offer much comfort to Visaggi and Godfrey, my sample actually closely tracked the distribution of these genera in both CC10 and CC9+10. Gray shark teeth (Carcharhinus spp.) dominated in all three samples. The better match overall with my sample was with the combined float CC9+10.

Anomalies? Sure. I found no cow shark teeth (Notorynchus primigenius) on this day, and my handful of lemon shark teeth (Negaprion eurybathrodon) and hammerhead shark teeth (Sphyrna laevissima) represented a much larger percentage of my sample than in either of the others.

Knowing that I was collecting for distributional analysis made a difference. As noted, I set out to act as a vacuum for much of the day, as a result I chased down all stray teeth (at least for awhile), painfully bending frozen fingers to pick yet another tooth from the waves, from under a downed tree, or from a chink in a clayey block of fallen cliff face. This may account for my luck with lemon and hammerhead shark teeth which are smallish teeth and, on another day, ones I might otherwise have skipped or missed. That doesn’t explain why my sample was missing other little teeth that did show up in the CC10 and CC9 samples, though still at marginal rates.

While I was on the beach, I was continuously comparing this day to the myriad others I’d spent gathering teeth in this same area. For much of the time, I bemoaned how bereft of the really good stuff – read the “large, rare, and unusual” – the beach was. They had taken an inopportune leave of absence. Then, I had one of those moments when I felt I’d stepped into some sort of parallel fantasy universe, actually, the fantasy universe of fossil hunters. In this universe, the fossil gods deigned to reward me. Almost everywhere I looked, there were wonderful teeth, one stuck in the sand, black glistening crown pointing to the cliff top, another two tumbling together in the surf, another one nestling next to the prize I had just grabbed with a sharp intake of my breath. It didn’t last long, but it was grand while it did, and all the while, I was sure it made my sample on this day totally irrelevant. But, not so. The good stuff either fit into expected categories or was outweighed by the other teeth gathered earlier. Besides, who was I kidding, my sample, despite any scientific gloss I tried to give it, was probably irrelevant from the outset

Conclusion

Moral of the story – one day’s collection does not a valid sample make, though it’s not bad.
 
Nature Blog Network