Showing posts with label natural history museums. Show all posts
Showing posts with label natural history museums. Show all posts

Thursday, November 30, 2023

Fossil Preparation: View From The Cheap Seats

Fossil preparators play a critical role in shaping the fossil specimens we see on display in natural history museums.  I spent several years as a volunteer in the FossiLab at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History surrounded by people doing this kind of work.  (I don’t think I’ve ever confessed on this blog that I was a FossiLab volunteer, though it was probably quite obvious.  Also, I don’t consider the microscope work I did with microfossils brought in from the field to be fossil preparation.)  This post is my attempt, sitting in the cheap seats, to cheer on the preparators, and to consider some of the complicated issues that greater transparency in delineating their roles appears to raise.

The newest incarnation of the glass-walled FossiLab is located at one end of the Fossil Hall and provides visitors with a look at volunteers working with fossils.  Its opening was celebrated in a piece in Smithsonian Magazine.  (Bedford, 2019.  Full citations to all references are at the end of this post.)  Many of the volunteers around me in the previous versions of the lab in which I worked were, in my estimation, fossil preparators expertly removing matrix from bones and teeth; using air scribes to reveal fragile plant fossils or uncover teeth in a jaw bone; fashioning archival housing to store and cradle heavy or fragile fossils; making realistic, detailed molds and casting fossil bones; carefully gluing fossil fragments back into coherent wholes; and so on.  At each step, they made decisions, alone or in consultation with professional preparators or scientists, which, whether big or small, influenced the content and contours of the fossils upon which they worked – adding or, on occasion, subtracting value.  What these people in the lab were (and are) doing in the “fish bowl” of the FossiLab may well offer onlooking museum visitors access to the most important paleontological insight they could gain from a visit to the museum:  fossils, despite their biological and paleontological origins in deep time, are also the products of human hands.

In a recent, provocative article titled Fossils Are Shaped by People.  Does That Matter?, Asher Elbein describes two realities:  (1) fossils on display in museums and elsewhere are human-mediated reconstructions of ancient life, and (2) the mediators are fossil preparators who largely and unfairly do not receive the credit due them.   (Elbein, 2023.)  The dynamic of these two realities is delineated in fine grain by Caitlin Donahue Wylie in the case studies that formed the foundation for her book analyzing fossil preparation in university and museum labs.  (Wylie, 2021a.)  Though the activities on display in a glass-walled lab in a museum might lead some to think fossils are being created, Wylie writes, “Preparators do not ‘make’ fossils from scratch; rather, they make fossils into specimens.”  (Wylie, 2021a, p. 3)  This is a crucial distinction and part of the process of “preparing knowledge.”

The label "preparator" seems inconsistently applied in the literature, leaving me confused as to when the term is used to describe only employed staff preparators, or used more broadly to encompass volunteers as well.  (Of course, my lack understanding is not an uncommon state of affairs as any reader of this blog will confirm).   Wylie writes,

Preparators don’t have PhDs or authorship on publications. They receive no formal training or methodological protocols. To distinguish themselves from low-skill, instruction-following technicians, preparators portray their practices as creative and artistic. Moreover, the majority of people who prepare fossils are volunteers, not staff. (Wylie, 2021a, p. 11.)

What am I to conclude from a passage like this?  Does she embrace volunteers as preparators or draw some sort of distinction?  Are "preparators" different (paid and on staff?) from volunteers "who prepare fossils?"  In an article, she describes a person working in a fossil lab as a "volunteer fossil preparator."  (Wylie, 2012b, p. 14.)  But others who have read her treatise find that she makes precise and hard distinctions as to fossil lab roles.  A recent reviewer of her book asserts the following (presumably reflecting their reading of what Wylie is describing):

Outnumbering both paleontologists and preparators, are the volunteers.  Volunteers differ from fossil preparators sometimes via skill, but always in terms of professionalization and responsibility.  Volunteers prepare fossils, but do not make decisions about how. . . .

So, the preparation of fossils relies on a network of paleontologists, who don't know how to prepare but do know how to interpret, preparators, who do not interpret, but prepare and decide how to prepare, and volunteers, who simply prepare, turning to preparators for guidance.  (Currie, 2023, p. 4.  "Simply prepare" is a singularly inappropriate and misleading phrase for any kind of fossil preparation work.)

Is Adrian Currie providing an accurate reading of Wylie?  I think such a hard and fast separation of preparators from volunteers misses an important aspect of the dynamic at play in fossil labs.  There is a sharing of skills and roles in the preparator universe.  So, in this post, rightly or wrongly, I use the label expansively to describe both professionals and volunteers.  In my view, preparators are often volunteers, young and old, elsewhere employed or retired.  Staff preparators may oversee and train volunteer preparators, but they do not make up the lion’s share of people who do this work.  And volunteer preparators have a significant influence on fossils' transition to specimens.

Unlike paleontologists who follow a path of rigorous and lengthy academic preparation to reach their professional status, preparators in general have no structured, widely accepted course of study.  Wylie has observed:

There is no specific training or certification required to work as a preparator; preparators teach novices on the job through informal supervision and advice.  They draw on skills from their diverse backgrounds to free fossils from rock and piece them together. (Wylie, 2021b, p. 14.)

There is a movement to professionalize the fossil preparation field, delineating what it should take to be hired as a preparator.  For instance, with support from the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, a group of professional preparators has identified the competencies that should underlie fossil preparation.  (Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, 2011.)  Further, there are models of programs to train volunteers in preparation skills and attitudes.  The Smithsonian's FossiLab was the setting for one such program which trained and screened volunteers who then staffed the lab going forward.  (Jabo, et al., 2010; Brown, et al., 2010.)

Context setting is important here.  Much of the concern about transparency in the realm of fossil preparation focuses on vertebrate paleontology, the field that produces the fossil skeletons that are the megastars of natural history museums and the objects of out-of-control bidding in fossil auctions worldwide.  Wylie posits that there is a strict division of labor in vertebrate paleontology when it comes to fossil preparation.  She states that vertebrate paleontologists for the most part don't know how to do the preparation work that enables them to study their specimens.  In contrast, invertebrate paleontologists do.  (Wylie, 2021a, p. 12.)  Nevertheless, it seems to me that, though the concerns and stakes may be less for invertebrate fossils, many of the same issues surrounding fossil preparation remain.  (It's not always clear in the literature on fossil preparation whether or when this vertebrate/invertebrate distinction is being applied.) 

Preparators as described by Elbein and Wylie are, to the outside world, largely invisible participants in the process of translating fossils into specimens.  Wylie argues that the absence of due credit (e.g., in publications) to preparators, and their relatively low status in institutional hierarchies mean that “scientists effectively reify the more visible products and people of science:  facts and scientists.”  (Wylie, 2021a, p. 9)  This ends up obscuring the actual process through which fossils are recovered from deep time, a process that introduces a subjectivity to the “facts,” and that is a blend of artistry and science.  In essence, a call for crediting the work of fossil preparators is a call to make that blend known, highlighting who did the preparation and what they did.

Though from what I observed in my years of volunteering in the lab, all of this rings true, but I am having a hard time seeing the form that the desired and deserved credit for fossil preparators should take.  Let me start by highlighting two fossils from my collection representing extremes of the credit issue.


The fish fossils are from the genus Knightia.  These are fresh water herrings from the Green River Formation in Wyoming and date back to the Eocene (roughly 50 million years ago).  That is all the background I have on these fish.  I don’t know precisely where they were found.  More to the point, I don’t know if what I have at hand is the slab of limestone matrix exactly as it was exposed in the field or whether some preparator worked on the slab to expose more of the fish before sending it into the commercial market where I bought it.  No record of what happened to the fossils on this slab means no way to give any credit.

This fossil is a trilobite, Kainops raymondi, found in the Haragan Formation in Oklahoma and dating back to the Lower Devonian (400 or more million years ago).  This specimen was prepared by Marc Behrendt, a preparator who serves the commercial market.  I purchased this fossil from him and received detailed photographs delineating many of the steps in the process of removing matrix from the trilobite.  Giving credit for this one is a slam dunk.

There is a broad middle ground between these two extremes, but complications seem to arise at every turn.  For instance, as I witnessed it, the fossil preparation process can be a communal project in which multiple people have a hand.  How is credit granted in that case?  Those who did the most work?  The most important?  Only the professional staff preparators?  How should any of this be measured?  At a minimum, some sort of paper trail of the preparation process seems in order.

On the other hand, if a single preparator works largely alone to turn a fossil into a specimen, there’s not much challenge in identifying to whom the credit should be given.  Even in that case, the process of rendering credit should depend upon record keeping delineating not only who worked on the fossil but what they did.

The issue of documenting the preparation process poses a challenge.  As Wylie has written, “crucially, preparators leave few written records.”  (Wylie, 2021a, p. 59.)  This has some disquieting consequences.  Researchers may be at some removed from the preparation process, remaining largely ignorant of what was done to the fossil.  Wylie observes, “This lack of record keeping and supervision grants preparators de facto power over their techniques.”  (Wylie, 2021a, p. 59.)  Perhaps it's not surprising, as Elbein writes, “Many experts argue that preparators deserve both recognition and scrutiny.”  (Elbein, 2022.)  Transparency is a two-edged sword that may reshape the contours of the role of the fossil preparator.

A different set of issues arises when one considers how to give credit to preparators.  I wrote a post  nearly a decade ago about a small mammal skeleton from the Late Cretaceous that was then on display at the National Museum of Natural History.

It’s a lovely skeleton, but what was on display was not an actual set of bones, but a cast of a specimen for which only some 30 percent of the actual bones were recovered (that’s still a very high percentage).  Here’s a picture of the label attached to the skeleton.

The collector is listed as Mike Triebold.  With minimal effort, the curious could follow that clue to the preparation of the skeleton by Triebold Paleontology, Inc. which Triebold headed and to the Rocky Mountain Dinosaur Resource Center which he founded.  This label doesn’t go as far as it could to make the preparation transparent to a museum researcher or visitor.  That said, how much detailed information should be given?  Just who had a hand in the preparation?  Some gauge of how much and what kind of preparation was involved?

Attribution of some aspects of the role that fossil preparators have played with individual specimens should made explicit.  Research papers might more consistently acknowledge and, within reason, describe the work done to prepare specimens.  Laboratory records could record who did what (though preparators would still remain largely invisible to the public).  This attribution need not be as significant as was the case with Opisthiamimus gregori, a newly identified Jurassic reptile.  The authors of the research article in which the new species was named wrote:

The species epithet ‘gregori’ recognizes Joseph Gregor, a dedicated Smithsonian volunteer who skillfully prepared the holotype and referred specimens. (DeMar, 2022, p. 6.)

These are challenging issues with no simple answers given the myriad variables at play in the process of preparing fossils.  I think it can only be helpful to make more explicit the role that preparators, whether professional or volunteer, play and, in doing so, give the general public a nuanced and more accurate understanding of what is on display.  Fossil preparation is important work that, whether we recognize it or not, directly influences how we view and understand fossils.

Sources

Bailey Bedford, Smithsonian Puts Backstage Fossil Preparation Center Stage in its New Fossil Hall, Smithsonian Magazine, October 16, 2019.

Matthew Brown, et al., The Smithsonian Institution’s Exhibit Fossil Preparation Lab Volunteer Training Programme, Part II:  Training and Evaluating Student Preparators, Geological Curator, Volume 9, Number 3, September, 2010.

Adrian Currie, Cleaning, sculpting or preparing? Scientific knowledge in Caitlin Wylie’s Preparing Dinosaurs, Biology & Philosophy, Volume 38, Number 10, 2023. 

David G. DeMar, Jr., et al., A nearly complete skeleton of a new eusphenodontian from the Upper Jurassic Morrison Formation, Wyoming, USA, provides insight into the evolution and diversity of Rhynchocephalia (Reptilia: Lepidosauria), Journal of Systematic Palaeontology, Volume 22, Issue 1, 2022.

Asher Elbein, Fossils Are Shaped by People.  Does That Matter?, Undark Magazine, November 11, 2023.

Steven J. Jabo, The Smithsonian Institution’s Exhibit Fossil Preparation Lab Volunteer Training Programme, Part I:  Design and Recruitment, Geological Curator, Volume 9, Number 3, 2010.

Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, Defining the Professional Vertebrate Fossil Preparator:  Essential Competencies, 2011.

Caitlin Donahue Wylie, Preparing Dinosaurs:  The Work Behind the Scenes, 2021a.

Caitlin Donahue Wylie, What Fossils Preparators Can Teach Us About More Inclusive Science, Issues in Science and Technology, Fall, 2021b.

Tuesday, March 31, 2020

Pandemic Days ~ Missing the Wonders of Fossils in Natural History Museums

The medical doctor and science essayist Lewis Thomas was once asked to be part of a gathering to create a list of the Seven Wonders of the Modern World.  He declined the invitation given his time constraints, but continued to mull over what he’d choose as the seven and, finally, penned an essay on the topic.  He began by considering the surprising richness and complexity of what we mean by wonder:
Wonder is a word to wonder about.  It contains a mixture of messages:  something marvelous and miraculous, surprising, raising unanswerable questions about itself, making the observer wonder, even raising skeptical questions like, “I wonder about that.”  Miraculous and marvelous are clues, both words come from an ancient Indo-European root meaning simply to smile or to laugh.  Anything wonderful is something to smile in the presence of, in admiration (which, by the way, comes from the same root, along with, of all telling words, “mirror”).  (Late Night Thoughts on Listening to Mahler’s Ninth Symphony, 1983, p. 55-56.)
While sheltering-in-place, I have gone in search of wonders not of the modern world, but of deep time, that is, I've gone looking for fossils, which are among the objects that make me wonder and smile.  I tried to do this by using online virtual tours to explore the holdings of natural history museums, here in the United States and elsewhere in the world.  Though there are tours to be had in some natural history museums, I was surprised to find that the vast majority of those in this country appear to offer none.  The same seems to apply to these museums worldwide.  I wonder if the experience of this pandemic will change that reality when these institutions are once again unshuttered.

At some point, many of those that do feature virtual tours partnered for their creation with the Google Cultural Institute, a non-profit entity founded in 2011.  These tours rely on the use of Street View Trolleys, the same camera technology used on automobiles to create Google Maps and Google Earth.


(This image of a trolley was taken from a YouTube video on the use of trolleys in cultural venues.)

American Museum of Natural History

I first stumbled on this Google project when I visited the American Museum of Natural History in New York City where the “Exploration” page offered a link to a virtual tour of the museum from “Google Arts and Culture” (the tour link is near the bottom of the page).

Here is the opening view of the virtual tour.  In this post, when the word “view” is underlined and highlighted it is an active link which will take you to where in the tour I captured the image.  Please note that most of the images shown in this post will not be precisely the views that will open when the "view" link is clicked.  Apparently any zooming in or out, or rotating that I did fails to fully register with the URLs used to create the links.


This beginning was actually a bit disappointing because the view failed to identify precisely where I was in the museum.

The images at the bottom of the opening shot link to specific areas of the museum that can be toured.  But, again, none of them are identified.  I clicked on the Tyrannosaurus rex image figuring there had to be fossils there.

This is the view that greeted me.


Fossils for sure, but a somewhat bizarre opening shot of this part of the museum’s dinosaur collection.  I was encouraged that the sign could be read ("in person," it is readable).  That had been a major concern going into this and, with care, most signs shown in this museum are readable.

Any view in the tour can be manipulated – zoomed in or out, rotated up, down, right, or left.  Arrows on the floor offer a way to move to another location offering another perspective.  For example, from the opening shot of the T. rex just presented, I zoomed out a bit and rotated up, generating this more impressive view.


I moved to one end of the hall and turned and captured the view below that peers down the length of the hall.  This shot nicely captures the way in which the American Museum of Natural History has chosen to display its dinosaurs – not within their environment or within the context of multidimensional stories, but by taxonomic groupings.


I wandered through the dinosaur holdings at the museum for awhile but, despite some wonderful fossils, I came away disappointed.  While touring, I had little sense of precisely where I was in any hall or, for that matter, in the museum as a whole.  I felt disconnected from the museum and its specimens, very much a stranger remaining at some remove from what was on display.  Symptomatic of this was the very skimpy information that I received when I clicked on the small images that, on occasion, appeared, associated with a specific item in an exhibit.  All rather perfunctory.  Did museum staff actually oversee and direct the creation of the tour?  Doubtful.

A Very Few Natural History Museums in Britain and Europe

The Google Cultural Institute website offers access to a wide array of tours of cultural institutions, including some natural history museum.  Links to 49 “collections” came up when I searched for “natural history” on the Institute’s website, most of which were museums.  Only 27 offered virtual tours.

I will only share a bit of what I experienced when I toured a few of those museums.  I spent most time at just three:  the Natural History Museum, London, Natural History Museum, Berlin, and the Natural History Museum, Vienna.

Yes, there are some fascinating fossils that one can view on these tours, with an emphasis on dinosaurs.  The issues I identified with the virtual tour of the American Museum of Natural History apply to these museums' tours in spades.  Worse, reading signs was difficult; I found most to be unreadable (and not because of any language barrier).  It does seem that signage overall in these institutions is scarce.  Are museum signs with heavy doses of explanatory text mostly an American phenomenon?

As I wandered through these museums, I began to explore the awe inspiring architecture of some of the buildings that house these collection.  Perhaps the architecture alone might the object of a virtual tour.  To wit, consider this view of part of the 19th century home of the Natural History Museum, Vienna.


I suspect that the limitations I’ve highlighted above are true of all virtual tours of natural history museums generated by the Google Cultural Institute’s Street View Trolley.  A far better approach, I would argue, is for museum staff to curate virtual tours actively with a structured message and the desired visitors’ experience in mind.  One museum has taken that approach.

Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History

I admit that I am biased in favor of the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History (I volunteered there for several years and have often extolled its virtues in the pages of this blog).  Of the virtual tours I took for this post, the crown jewel is that offered the the National Museum.

For this post, I limited myself to the recently reopened and thoroughly renovated Fossil Hall – Deep Time, and came away, once again, enraptured by the breadth and depth of what there is to see and learn in that hall, even if one just visits virtually.  As fashioned by the Smithsonian, this tour does not give one full control over where in the hall the cursor finds active links and that, I think, is a good thing.  It’s a healthy function of how much the tour was intentionally planned and designed.  This is a tour de force.  (My apologies, the first thing to go with sustained cabin fever may be the joke filter.)

The museum’s various virtual tours are accessible through a portal page.  Clicking on the Permanent Exhibits icon (a bit down the page) opens up a view of the rotunda on the first floor.  As seen in the image below, a floor diagram floats in the upper right hand corner, identifying the permanent exhibits on this floor.  (The floor plan can be closed but I often kept it open to remind me of where I was.)  In each exhibit, small bubble icons mark where a visitor can go.  If one hovers over an icon, the location is identified.  The Fossil Hall (green on the floor plan) is awash in icons.  Clicking on one places the visitor in the exhibit at that location with a 360 degree view that can be manipulated.  (Be warned that many of the views afforded of different specimens suffer a bit from reflections off the display cases.  Site credit is given as follows:  “Imagery and coding by Loren Ybarrondo.”)


Here are just a very few of my favorite views from the Fossil Hall tour.  None of these subsequent images is accompanied below by a web address because this tour does not associate a unique address with any specific place in the hall.

Of course, the tableau of a Tyrannosaurus rex about to dine on a fallen Triceratops horridus has become this hall’s iconic image:


The completeness and detail of many fossils from the Green River Formation (Eocene, 54 to 48 million years ago) make them quite compelling.  Here is one display of these fossils in the hall.  While on the tour, I could move closer to the exhibit, study some of the specimens, and read explanatory text.


Another of my favorite features of the Fossil Hall is this display of marine fossils from the Late Cretaceous.  This view centers on a large mosasaur, a Tylosaurus, that holds a neat secret.


Moving close to this mosasaur, one discovers that, somewhat obscured by its ribs, is a small clutch of bones mounted on an illustrated stomach.  Apparently, this mosasaur died shortly after making a meal of a plesiosaur which, in turn, had recently eaten a smaller species.  A fossil find that kept on giving.


No point uploading more images, the virtual tour "in person" is well worth taking, feeding that sense of wonder over deep time.

As noted at the outset of this post, Lewis Thomas ultimately did choose his Seven Wonders of the Modern World.  What an eclectic array of object from the natural world he chose.  Not what I would ever have anticipated, but they are objects that generated profound questions for him, offered up mysteries that challenged accepted wisdom, and exhibited complex, surprising, and awe-inspiring behavior.  Wonders.

The seven in the rank order he gave them beginning with his top choice are:  the planet Earth (a "living system, an immense organism, . . . ."); thermophilic bacteria (those that live in environments with extremely high temperatures that heretofore were thought inimicable to life); the Oncideres beetle (whose complex behavior told Thomas how little we know about nature); the scrapie virus (an infectious agent causing brain disease in sheep and goats whose composition and behavior defied explanation); the olfactory receptor cell (a neuron living far from the brain); the termite (the miracle of its collectivity); and a human child (to Thomas, human childhood is essentially for learning language which creates our wondrous collectivity).

These days, it is rather hard to “to smile in the presence of” the full range of the wonders of the natural world, particularly the one that all the world's people are experiencing now, but Thomas, I think, could have managed it.

Sunday, September 14, 2014

A Different Way to See Fossil Skeleton Mounts


Memorandum
To:  Myself
Subject:  Fossil Skeleton Mounts

Next time you are in a natural history museum (one with its fossil halls not undergoing renovation, so, forget the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History), approach a fossil skeleton mount (that sine qua non of natural history museums), and try your damnedest to get beyond that initial awe-inspiring view.  Move as close as you’re allowed and look for those telltale signs of how that skeleton is being held together, how it’s holding its pose.  Look for the armature, that construct of metal that keeps the bones in place.  Yes, some armatures are internal, but a glimpse of a bit of metal sneaking through joints, from inside one bone into another, might be had (unless the joints are filled in with plaster).  An external armature might be as obvious as that holding up the neck and torso of the Apatosaurus skeleton dominating the Peabody Museum of Natural History’s Great Hall,



or it might be mostly hidden on the backside of the bones.

Look carefully at the bones.  Try to identify which of the skeleton’s bones are real fossils and which are casts.  Museums seem to be doing a better job these days of ensuring that fossil bones and casts can be distinguished from each other.  On older mounts this may not be so easy given that fossils and casts were often painted the same color.

If fossil bones can be distinguished from casts, consider the fate of those real fossil bones in such a mount.


It’s not clear when I’ll be able to follow the guidance in this memo.  [Later edit:  I will be able to follow the memo a lot sooner than I thought.  In the original version of this post, I wrote that "there are no fossil skeleton mounts on display, at the moment, at the NMNH (my natural history museum home)."  That's wrong.  There's at least one on display in the Sant Ocean Hall, a Basilosaurus, which is an ancient whale.  See Addendum at end.]  “Hatcher,” the cast of a Triceratops, which had been the sole dinosaur standing publicly in the museum after the Fossil Halls shuttered their doors earlier this year, is now behind temporary walls on the third floor as a new Late Cretaceous display takes shape around it and “Stan,” the museum’s T. rex cast.  When it opens in late November, this display will be up for five years as the Fossil Halls undergo their total makeover.

It’s not a coincidence that my interest in the process and consequences of including real fossils in skeleton mounts has taken flight just when the NMNH Fossil Halls are off-limits.  Most folks would be interested in the construction of the new NMNH displays, but, in my contrarian (perhaps better read “perverse”) fashion, I have become focused on the flipside of that, that is, on the dismantling of the myriad mounts that graced the Fossil Halls for the past century.

Some wonderful pictures of aspects of this deconstruction can be found in various postings in the Smithsonian blog Digging the Fossil Record:  Paleobiology at the Smithsonian.  To date, primarily featured in these posts is the taking apart and moving of the casts of “Hatcher” and “Stan” (cast mounts really aren't my concern here).

Visitors to the NMNH can witness some of that fossil mount deconstruction if they visit the museum’s FossiLab on the second floor and look in through the windows and watch the volunteers at work.  A recent entry in the Digging the Fossil Record blog highlighted the reopening of the FossiLab (which had briefly been shielded from public view in its previous location down in the Fossil Halls) and noted that some volunteers in the lab will be engaged in taking mounts apart and creating storage containers for the disarticulated bones.  The blogger (sadly, anonymous) comments that:
Dismantling skeletons is challenging.   Some of the mounts were built a long time ago and, since mounting techniques have changed a lot over time, nearly every mount was constructed in a different way.  Add in the problem that some of the bones are extremely fragile, and it can take some puzzling to figure out how to tease the mounts apart safely.  Once the bones are free of the armature they are photographed, logged into our collections database, and placed in archival storage where they will be preserved for scientific study and, perhaps, remounting for a future exhibit.
What happens to fossil bones when they are included in such mounts, particularly those “built a long time ago”?  There is literature out there about that.  A particularly depressing account comes from Robert L. Evander, senior principal preparator at the American Museum of Natural History, in a 2009 piece titled Armature Damage to a Mounted Specimen (this full-text link is listed on the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology’s Preparator’s Resources site).

The fossil mount in question is the skeleton of a glyptodont, a large (some were car-sized), armored, armadillo-like mammal, that dates back to at least the Miocene (23 to 5 million years ago) and which went extinct about 10,000 years ago.  Evander basically reverse-engineered the mount because the American Museum of Natural History’s Adam Hermann, who prepared the mount from the fossil bones in 1916 – 1917, left no detailed account of how that particular mount was constructed.  This was the final fossil skeleton he mounted, so, it may reflect the best of Hermann’s work.  Writes Evander,
Adam Hermann’s free mounts are deceptive.  The bones appear to be gently mounted upon cleverly-hidden external armatures closely shaped to the bones.  The few visible drill holes seem to be attaching individual bones to this external armature.
How did he achieve this deception?  Well, he drilled some 100 holes lengthwise into articulated fossil bones in order to run wires through them as part of the internal armature.  Spaces in joints were filled with plaster.  The external armature was shaped on the basis of plaster casts of the bones and was then attached to the fossil bones by more drilling through the bones, and the insertion of many more nuts and bolts.  Here’s an illustration of parts of this method from a piece Hermann wrote explaining his fossil preparation and mounting techniques; the caption tells the story (Modern Laboratory Methods in Vertebrate Palæontology, Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History, Volume XXVI, 1909, p. 318):


Evander discovered that, because the armatures are harder than the bones, the points at which the armatures are screwed or bolted to the fossil bones are places where cracks and breaks have developed.

Conclusion?  Disaster.  Writes Evander of this fossil skeleton and others mounted by Hermann a century ago,
In some measure, Hermann’s mounting has adversely affected scientific access to these specimens, which will never be freely available to study in the disarticulated state.  Individual postcranial elements cannot be extracted easily.  Realistically, these mounts are permanent.
It is ironic (from our perspective a century later) that in the same 1909 piece of his, Hermann cautioned,
I therefore say, that a beginner in a palæontological laboratory never ought to be trusted with a delicate and rare specimen.  In my experience, I have seen irremediable damage done on account of poor judgment.  (p. 331)
Because Hermann-like treatment of fossil bones in mounted skeletons continued well into the 20th century, Evander finishes with a word for us frequenters of natural history museums:
Thus the mounted specimens seen in the museums of the world may be more fragile than they appear.
Though the doors to the NMNH’s Fossil Halls are shut, I wondered whether photographs I’d taken previously of its fossil skeleton mounts might show something about the mounting process employed.  One entry in Digging the Fossil Record includes a couple of pictures of the work on dismantling the museum’s Irish Elk with its massive antlers.  This particular mount, which went on display in 1872, was the Smithsonian’s first mount utilizing real fossil bones.  (A post on the superb blog Dinosours! [sic] discusses this skeleton mount.)  That prompted me to look at pictures I’d taken of the Irish Elk for a previous post on my blog.  The picture below (looking head on) shows the animal’s left antler and the wiring that holds up.  A couple of seemingly benign metal supports appear to cradle the antler from its ventral side.


But, the following picture (taken from behind the animal) suggests that all is not so benign.  The “cradling” arms are apparently bolted through the antler to a metal plate on the backside of the antler.  Further, part of a metal armature can be seen coming from the skeleton up onto the antler.  This too is apparently bolted to the antler.  I have marked several of these bolt heads.


I found a bit more in my collection of photos.  A set of photos of the NMNH’s Brontotherium hatcheri (taken for a blog posting about this rhinoceros-like herbivore related to horses that lived some 40 million years ago) may also be revealing.  Unfortunately, I cannot be certain when this mount was created (the fossil bones were discovered by John Bell Hatcher in 1887) nor exactly which of the bones in this skeleton are real.  But, the Smithsonian’s Collections Search Center describes this specimen as including the following fossil bones:  “skull elements, lower jaw, Axial element, thoracic vertebra, Appendicular elements, pelvic girdle, phalange.”  Here’s a picture of the rump of the specimen.  I’ve marked two places that particularly drew my attention.


The lower arrow points to part of the external armature, where it is bolted onto the skeleton.


Do these go into fossil bone?  I don’t know.  I’d love to be able to see this skeleton again.

The upper arrow points to part of the pelvic girdle (which is listed as fossilized bone but perhaps not all of it is) where a bolt head is obvious.


I assume this bolt attaches to the external armature which runs behind the bone, and I believe that this bolt runs through fossil bone, not plaster.  Of interest is the crack that radiates from the bolt head.  Evander would probably not be surprised.

Despite all of this, I’m not prepared to let the other shoe drop, the one that signals opposition to inclusion of any actual fossils in free standing skeleton mounts.  That’s a major bone (pun intended) of contention in paleontological circles where there is concern, not just for the damage done in the mounting process, but the potential damage incurred by being in such a mount for the long term, subject to changes in temperature and humidity, vibrations, and other harmful stresses.  Though mounting techniques have changed for the better, I may still be heading in the direction of advocating for nothing real in free-standing mounts (I would not be alone in holding that position).

For the time being, memo writer, I will consider such mounts from that different perspective and with a great deal of concern.

ADDENDUM

Ben, author of the blog Dinosours!, commented on this posting (see below) and asked my reaction to more "gentle" mounting techniques.  In my response, I referred to Digging the Fossil Record and a post there by Matt Carrano, Smithsonian Curator of Dinosauria, in which he stated that mounts in which fossil bones were drilled into were a thing of the past.  He included a photo of some of the sternum bones of an ancient whale currently on display at the NMNH; these bones were cradled in metal supports.  When I went back to his post, I was dismayed on two counts:  first, I should have quoted Carrano in my original post (I do in my response to Ben), and, second, I had completely overlooked the fossil skeleton mount of the ancient whale in the Sant Ocean Hall (which allowed me to make the erroneous assertion that, with the closing of the Fossil Halls, there weren't any still on display - indeed, there may still be others, my search continues).  I've had a chance to take a look at that whale skeleton (which includes real bones) and, though I tried, I found it difficult to really observe how all of it was mounted (sorry, memo writer) because the whole thing floats high overhead, suspended from the ceiling (and accompanied by two cast mounts).  Clearly, the sternum bones are being supported without drilling, as apparently are the vertebrae.  Also, real bone and cast are easily distinguishable, a good practice.  But, I cannot be so sure that some bolts aren't still penetrating real bone.  Unfortunately, I cannot get close enough to be sure.  Here is a picture of a few of the ribs and a flipper (real bone is darker and rougher).  Perhaps I'm just inclined to see it, but it does look to me as though some real bone may have been drilled into.


Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Museums Telling a New Natural History Story

My intention to write a post about the blog that the Paleobiology Department in the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History (NMNH) launched several months ago was reinforced when I came across Edward Rothstein’s review of the multi-million dollar “transformation” or “refashioning” of the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHM) (Beyond Dioramas:  Nature’s New Story, New York Times, August 3, 2013).  It struck me that both efforts – one a very expensive investment in the remaking of a museum and the other a low-cost digital activity with minimal financial outlay – present (to varying degrees) a critical element of the story that natural history museums are now sharing with their visitors, whether those visitors come to a physical structure or a website.  These museum are telling how scientists in the natural history fields do their work.

Rothstein, cultural critic of the New York Times, asserts that the natural history museum, in general, has been a lumbering beast, resistant to change, that is, until recently.  The beast’s evolution, he posits, is “quickening.”  So, what has changed for the NHM?  The essence of his somewhat rambling review seems to be that NHM chose to go “local” (read, Los Angeles) and focus on the “history of human interaction with nature.”  The tried and true elements of the natural history museum remain in the NHM – the dioramas from the 1920s and 1930s have their place along with the fossils.  But these are just a part of this museum’s landscape which now features local artifacts – to wit, the shoes and clothes Charlie Chaplin wore in City Lights, or a 1902 Tourist, a wooden car – topped off by the exhibit titled Becoming Los Angeles which presents the history of the peopling of the area.  Apparently, where this new approach most reveals its promise is in the Nature Lab in which children (and their parents) learn about the local Los Angeles fauna and are drawn into “citizen science” activities.  Rothstein labels the Nature Lab’s exhibits “among the most successful I have seen for children in a science museum.”

I must admit that I initially thought that the LA museum might have wandered too far afield in its efforts to remake itself (and appeal to a broader audience), but I have to remember the sweeping nature of what’s included in that term natural history.  Wooden cars and movie costumes are not a stretch.

In drawing visitors into a greater understanding of the “history of human interaction with nature,” the NHM appears to have embraced two disparate aspects of that objective.  The first centers on humans reshaping their natural environment (e.g., the Becoming Los Angeles exhibit).  Interesting and important, to be sure.  The second – how we humans learn about nature – is, for me, the more critical element.  This should be part of the heart and soul of the story that natural history museums are telling – how paleontologists, botanists, entomologists, and the other scientists in the natural history fields do their work.

Rothstein writes that the NHM’s Mammal and Dinosaur Halls now “hint” at this.  They seek to present the “interpretations” and “uncertainties” of the work.  Further, and more to the point, in some of these NHM exhibits,
[t]he emphasis is on how paleontologists learn and on how our understanding has changed.  Scientists appears in videos and panels, outlining arguments and demonstrating procedures.
I'll have to see them for myself to know whether hint is the appropriate verb.  Based on the description of the new Dinosaur Hall on the NHM's website, I come away feeling that the NHM is doing more than just hinting.  Of the three questions purportedly addressed by new Dinosaur Hall, one is "How do scientists know what they know?"  Luis Chiappe, Director of the NHM's Dinosaur Institute, is quoted as saying, “The new Dinosaur Hall has the potential of inspiring new generations of scientists, since this exhibition highlights discovery-based fieldwork, the experience of going outdoors and finding treasures, and then understanding how they fit within current scientific record.”

Amen to that.

A less significant but still an important contribution toward this refocusing of the natural history museum and its story is the blog launched by the Paleobiology Department at the Smithsonian's NMNH.  Getting beyond the “punny” title – Digging the Fossil Record:  Paleobiology at the Smithsonian – is well worth the effort because typically the content is very interesting and the blog’s authors successfully explicate the complicated.  (Unfortunately and rather puzzling, the identity of the writers of individual posts isn’t always provided.) The tone is light and engaging.  Altogether, it’s a fun blog to monitor.

In its initial post, the blog sought to entice readers:
If you have ever wondered what paleontologists do in the field or wished you could see Smithsonian fossils that aren’t on display, subscribe to this blog for behind-the-scenes photos, field reports from our scientists, research news, archival images, paleo art, and many other stories about our collection and our work, past and present.
So, far in its brief existence, Digging the Fossil Record has lived up to its own PR, offering a fairly wide mix of content, though, to date, it’s been largely dominated by accounts of Smithsonian scientists doing field work.  Among these posts have been a multipart series about collecting plant fossils at a Permian site in north-central Texas, a two-part series focused on core drilling in Tanzania in order to collect the fossil shells of marine microorganisms, and, most recently, a five-parter on a collecting trip to the North Dakota badlands (more on that one in a moment).

Though other kinds of offerings have been on the menu, they’ve been a bit sparser.  The blog has explored, among other subjects, some of the prep work being done by volunteers in the Museum’s FossiLab on material brought back from the field, the background of the new T. rex skeleton coming to the Smithsonian (just in time for the disruption of the complete remodeling of all of the paleontological offerings at the NMNH, including the Dinosaur Hall), and the life’s work of a premier, though largely forgotten, dinosaur hunter, Charles W. Gilmore, a curator at the NMNH for a couple of decades in the first half of the 20th Century.

The North Dakota badlands series, titled From the Field:  Putting Dinosaurs in Their Place, is a good example of what the blog has to offer (besides titles with puns).  The collecting trip is placed firmly in context.  In preparation for an exhibit opening next year that will “flesh out” the natural environment in which the Triceratops and Tyrannosaurus rex lived, the NMNH team went in search of fossils of “small vertebrates, mollusks, plants, and, of course, dinosaurs . . . ” in the Late Cretaceous Hell Creek Formation.  It was eye opening to this amateur collector that the objective of the trip was that clear cut – gather the material needed for an exhibit on a Late Cretaceous ecosystem.  For me, setting out with such a definitive goal would be a certain recipe for disappointment.  But that’s where experience and expertise enter the equation.  The team included paleobotanist Kirk Johnson (also the Director of the NMNH) who has often collected plants in this area.  He led the team to favorite and productive spots.

Methods employed in the field are on display in these posts.  Small quarries are dug, rocks are moved and split, revealing the impressions of plants within.



(The photo of the multiple leaf impressions was taken by Diana Marsh; that of the palm leaf was taken by Kirk Johnson.  These pictures and one below were downloaded from the blog under the terms of use specified by the Smithsonian.)

Ancient river channels are crawled through in search of tiny fossil teeth and bones lying on the surface.  Matrix is shoveled into bags for more thorough searching back in the Museum’s FossiLab.  GPS devices are used to record precise locations of finds.  Sketches are made of the landscape, attending to the locations of different sedimentary layers.  Layers are measured with a Jacob’s staff (had to look that one up since the post in question offers no explanation).


(I could not find a credit for this photograph.)

One post describes a “bone walk” or biostratigraphic survey in which every visible fossil is collected, with its location noted, from one specific sedimentary layer.

These posts make it abundantly clear that this work, in general, is not one string of wonderful fossil discoveries; they well capture the painstaking nature of the work and the challenge of collecting under the hot North Dakota sun.

Perhaps most important to me is that any attentive reader of this series will learn that the field work is but one step in the process.  These badlands posts repeatedly emphasize that lab work awaits these finds – sifting through matrix for more vertebrate fossils, carefully exposing more of the leaves from the split rocks.  I hope that the blog will follow these fossils from the field through the lab, onto the curation process, and, finally, to display in the new exhibit opening in 2014 (or, if we're being really honest, sometimes to storage in plaster jackets or in drawers in some cabinets).  Now, that would certainly capture some of how the work of natural history is done.

Sadly, the small effort by the National Museum of Natural History’s Digging the Fossil Record blog is blunted because the blog is rather hidden (I originally wrote “buried”) on the Smithsonian’s busy website. Yes, there are some other offerings on the NMNH website that feature the processes of science, but these are too little and too secreted away.

Yet, hope springs eternal.  I look forward to seeing, in several years' time (possibly by 2019), the NMNH's totally remade paleontological offerings fully expressing this new story of natural history.

[Note:  As originally uploaded, this post perpetuated the misconception that the NMNH was renovating just its Dinosaur Hall.  All of its paleontological offerings are being redone as outlined in a Washington Post article from last year.]

Friday, November 26, 2010

The Very Real, Multidimensional Hadrosaurus foulkii ~ Convoluted History and Rejoinder to a Critic of Natural History Museums


At some point in the 1870s or possibly the very early 1880s, photographer James F. Jarvis set up his camera and array of equipment at the Smithsonian Castle and took photographs of the institution’s mounted skeleton of Hadrosaurus foulkii, a dinosaur from the Cretaceous period (about 146 to 66 million years ago).  From the glass negatives he prepared at the Smithsonian, Jarvis produced a stereoview or stereograph featuring the Hadrosaurus.  (Stereoviews or stereographs – cards whose dual mounted photographs generate a 3-D image when viewed through a stereoscope – have been considered previously on this blog.)

I recently added a copy of this stereoview to my collection.  The full face of this stereoview and a closeup of one of the two pictures are shown below.  The Hadrosaurus is prominent in the foreground, facing into the picture.  In front of it is a large Himmalayan tortoise shell from the Miocene epoch (about 23 to 5 million years ago), and in front of the tortoise is the restoration of an Irish elk, the Pleistocene epoch giant deer that went extinct some 11,000 years ago.



Jarvis was well known for the manufacture of stereoviews of Washington, D.C., and various series of stereoviews from government explorations of the western U.S..  For a period, he ranked among the country’s major producers of this popular photographic medium.

Originally, I thought it would be relatively easy to compose a posting on the subject of this specific stereoview.  Clearly, I had no clue about the richly convoluted the history of this mounted skeleton of Hadrosaurus.  Nor did I recognize that these photographs speak to a contemporary debate about the display of “fake” skeletons by natural history museums.  (Some of the sources I consulted are identified in the text; most are included in the discussion of sources at the end.)

Initially, though, I wanted to place a date on the stereoview, well, actually, the taking of the negative.  The Smithsonian has produced a fascinating webpage on stereoviews of the institution.  According to the information appearing there, beginning in 1874, the Hadrosaurus skeleton was on display in the Main Hall of the Smithsonian Building, a structure usually referred to as the Castle.  Then, in 1882, along with other skeletons and specimens, the Hadrosaurus was moved to the Smithsonian’s National Museum building.  This Jarvis stereoview shows the Castle’s Lower Main Hall looking east, which means it had to have been taken between 1874 and 1882.  Unfortunately, that doesn’t really narrow it down very much.

What was the source of the skeleton?  The fossilized bones of  a giant creature had been discovered in 1858 in Haddonfield, New Jersey, by Philadelphia lawyer and fossil hunter William Parker Foulke.  Foulke called in Joseph Leidy, a professor of anatomy at the University of Pennsylvania and curator at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia, who identified them as coming from a dinosaur, a term that had been coined by English paleontologist and biologist Richard Owen in the early 1840s.  This was the most complete dinosaur skeleton that had ever been found anywhere.  Leidy named the dinosaur Hadrosaurus foulkii (the genus name means “bulky lizard” and the species name recognizes Foulke).

A decade later, the English anatomist, scientific illustrator, and sculptor Benjamin Waterhouse Hawkins came on the scene, having traveled to the U.S. to create a dinosaur display for a new museum in New York City.  After consulting Leidy about the New York display, he undertook the task of mounting the Hadrosaurus skeleton for the Academy of Natural Sciences.  With assistance from Leidy and one of Leidy’s students, Edward Drinker Cope, Hawkins created a mounted dinosaur skeleton using plaster casts of the bones at hand and plaster reconstructions, based on educated guesses, of those that were missing.  This was the first mounted dinosaur skeleton ever produced and, as we all know, this kind of display was destined to become a staple of natural history museums worldwide.

The skeleton went on display at the Academy in late 1868, attracting throngs of visitors, so many that officials of the Academy took steps to reduce the number of visitors, curtailing the days it was open to the public and charging admission.  The success of the display apparently was not lost on other institutions that then sought to obtain their own copies; Hawkins produced several.  According to Richard C. Ryder, the Smithsonian received a copy sometime between March 1874 and mid 1875.

After being displayed in the Smithsonian Castle, the Smithsonian’s Hadrosaurus was moved in 1882 to the National Museum building where it remained until perhaps 1893 or 1894.  Ryder says that it was then sent to the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago, “only to be discarded when the museum moved to new quarters a decade later.”

Breathtakingly innovative for its time, Hawkins’ Hadrosaurus skeletons got some things right, and missed the boat on some others.  For instance, the posing of the Hadrosaurus in an upright, bipedal position reflected Leidy’s accurate understanding of the dinosaur.  But, the three-pronged supporting position of the hind legs and the tail, giving the creature a kangaroo-like appearance, was ultimately disproven by subsequent research.  The drawing below depicts current understanding of the positioning and use of the tail (the picture comes from the New Jersey Geological Survey).  The Academy’s clutch of Hadrosaurus bones lacked a skull, so Hawkins made one based on the head of an iguana lizard, a creative though erroneous solution to the problem.



One passing comment on Leidy’s student, Edward Drinker Cope.  Cope became one of the country’s foremost paleontologists and engaged in the famous no-holds-barred competition against Othniel Charles Marsh to find dinosaur fossils – the so-called Bone Wars.  This conflict had a Hadrosaurus connection.  Before the battle royal began, the two men spent what paleontologist Michael Novacek describes as “a friendly week together poking around Leidy’s old Haddonfield quarry for hadrosaur bones.”  Hoag Levins, in an article on his great website Finding the World’s First Dinosaur Skeleton:  Hadrosaurus foulkii, asserts that the Cope-Marsh conflict had its roots in this friendly time together.  Cope generously introduced Marsh to the managers of different pits from which dinosaur bones were being collected.  The falling out occurred when Cope learned that, shortly after they left the area, Marsh returned alone, money in hand, to bribe the managers to send him bones and word of what they had found.

Hawkins’ Hadrosaurus skeleton also has some bearing on a debate of sorts that involves natural history museums today.  Earlier this year, “Thomas H. Benton” (the pen name of William Pannapacker), a professor of English at Hope College, published a piece in The Chronicle of Higher Education entitled Getting Real at Natural-History Museums (July 1, 2010) in which he takes these museums to task for succumbing to the entertainment bug and for mounting displays that contain “fakes.”  Venturing into the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia with his daughter in search of the real dinosaur skeletons he remembered from his youth, he was dismayed to discover only replicas.  He asserts

Natural-history museums like the [Academy of Natural Sciences] emerged to provide exhibits that were reliably authentic and that could instruct the public and build the credibility of science in a period, like our own, in which pseudoscience had a strong hold on the general imagination.  Of course, the replicas in natural-history museums, unlike [P.T.] Barnum’s humbugs, present authentic science, but, over the last few generation, museums have become more willing to use substitutes in place of real artifacts.  It seemed like a good idea at the time. . . .

You could say that a fake skeleton educates as well as a real one, and it surely looks as good for publicity purposes.  But one of the fundamental attractions of natural-history museums – and museums in general – is the aura of authenticity and the power they have to inspire the imagination, particularly for children, in an era that is increasingly characterized by the virtual and the simulated.  That was not true when fossil replicas were first introduced – the changes were made with the best of intentions – but it is surely the case now.

Frankly, I am always suspicious of people who argue that there was once a “golden age” and that we’ve lost our way.  Too often that “golden age” proves to have been a mirage, the reality being nothing like what was remembered.  Clearly, that's the case in this instance.

A wonderful response to “Benton” was penned by Chris, a museum curator, on his blog Prerogative of Harlots (July 26, 2010).  He observes, “When Benton refers to fakes, he’s actually taking about casts – specifically the cast dinosaur skeletons that many museums exhibit in their galleries.”  Why do they do that?  For one thing, there are very few complete fossil skeletons.  Most are exceedingly incomplete.  So even a skeleton of an individual specimen that includes real bones will include many replicas of bone.  Chris points out that the dinosaur “Benton” remembers from his youth at the Academy was a composite, not the “real” thing.  Chris describes the precision behind the creation of casts, a process producing something that is

as close to the fossil as it’s possible to get without actually owning it.  Casts are heavily used in paleontology because of the scarcity of fossil specimens – they are exchanged between museums and sent out on loan to researchers.  We assign them catalog numbers and treat them in the same way as we would treat any museum specimen.

He argues, persuasively in my mind, that the answer to the question “Is it real?” when standing before a dinosaur skeleton cast is

Absolutely, in the sense that there was once an animal that looked like this, we have the bones to prove it, and this exhibit specimen could not have been made without those bones.

Hawkins’ Hadrosaurus foulkii itself constitutes another strong response to “Benton.”  From the very outset of museums displaying mounted dinosaur skeletons, they were real only in the sense that Chris described, not in the way “Benton” misremembered from his childhood and before.  Then and now, they draw crowds and inspire the imagination, regardless of whether this or that bone is rock or a cast.

One final small note, Hawkins is tied to the Hadrosaurus stereoview in another way; it’s his restoration of an Irish elk appearing in the background.


Sources

The Academy of Natural Science has some useful information on its website for the exhibit about Hadrosaurus foulkii that it mounted in 2009.

Richard C. Ryder wrote a very interesting piece on dinosaurs in stereoviews entitled Dinosaurs Through the Stereoscope, Stereoworld, March/April 1985.

For a great exploration of Hawkins’ work, including the process for creating the mounted Hadrosaurus skeleton, see The Art of Bones:  Nineteenth-century Artist Benjamin Waterhouse Hawkins Still Influences How Prehistoric Life is Represented Today, by Robert McCracken Peck, Natural History, December 2008 – January 2009.  This article was adapted from the book All in the Bones: A Biography of Benjamin Waterhouse Hawkins, by Valerie Bramwell and Robert M. Peck.

Among good sources of background on Hadrosaurus is When Dinosaurs Roamed New Jersey by William B. Gallagher, 1997.

The Cope-Marsh competition is described in many sources.  Time Traveler:  In Search of Dinosaurs and Ancient Mammals From Montana to Mongolia  by Michael Novacek (2002) includes a brief, concise overview of the Bone Wars.
 
Nature Blog Network